Brussels First Instance Tribunal, A. v Kingdom of Belgium, Nr. 2013/9033/A, 4 May 2015
The claimant is a Belgian national born in Palestine. He asserts that numerous products originating from Israeli settlements in occupied Palestinian land are commercialized in Belgium undr the label ‘Made in Israel’, in contravention with international law. According to A., authorizing this commercialisation makes Belgium complicit in the illegal occupation of Palestine and Israel’s violations of international humanitarian law. In light hereof, the claimant requests the Court to forbid the Belgian State to continue allowing the entry and sale of these products.
However, the Court declared his claim inadmissible on the grounds that A. did not have a personal, direct, concrete and legitimate interest. Contrary to what A. asserts, this interest cannot be derived from the direct applicability of jus cogens. Only people who have a direct and personal interest because of the violation of international laws, can turn to the courts.